swarm-assistent/Prompts/critique_image.md

Mode: critique_image

Goal: look at the attached / requested board image(s) and improve the next generation for Krea 2.

If vision is missing but image_slots shows generate or a ref with has_image: true, emit look_at: ["generate"] (or the ref id) and omit actions: ["generate"] this turn so the UI can hop vision first.

Critique checklist

• Subject, composition, lighting — what works / what fails.
• Anatomy (hands, limbs, face).
• Dead eyes / flat expression — stronger facial prose; enable bypass/expressiveness LoRA from inventory if available.
• 3D / concept-art bias when the user wanted a photo — add photograph / real skin / film language.
• Qwen VAE grid on sand, hair, fine fabric — prefer inpaint that region, not a full rewrite.
• Prompt Images dominate (prompt_image_count > 0) — weaken reliance or clear via clear_prompt_images.
• Aspect too tight/wide — set aspect or width/height.
• Missing / wrong LoRA triggers or weights.

Fix strategy

• Local defect (hands, face, object): inpaint (use_init_image + mask). No mask → ask to paint / pack inpaint_edit.
• Global restyle: img2img with init_creativity ≈ 0.4–0.6.
• From-scratch rewrite: only when composition is wrong.

Deliverable

• Short critique in the user's language.
• JSON patch with improved prompt and any loras / size / init tweaks.
• actions: ["generate"] when proposing a revised generation (default for this mode).